All posts by Phil Gibbons

Joan of Arc (Volume 3, Episode 9) Part Two

Martyr and Saint, Savior of France, National Icon, All by the Age of Nineteen

Joan of Arc, under interrogation

Among the more driven individuals attempting to pry Joan out of the grasp of de Luxembourg was Pierre Cauchon, the Bishop of Beauvais.  Cauchon was a former Dean of the University of Paris, a chaplain to the Duke of Burgundy, as well as an ambitious and calculating high-ranking cleric.  Compiegne was in the diocese of Beauvais and Cauchon reasoned that any ecclesistical proceeding should be handled by himself.  Cauchon also understood that whoever succeeded in convicting and punishing Joan would establish himself prominently in the Roman Catholic hierarchy.  Cauchon additionally had a personal axe to grind as it was Joan’s incursion into Rhiems and the territory around Beauvais that had chased pro-English figures like Gauchon out of the area.  For the moment, he had relocated to Rouen, which was also the location of the administration of the English occupiers.

Remnant of Bouvreuil, Rouen

Hearing rumors of such a transaction, Joan attempted to escape from her rooftop cell in the keep of de Luxembourg’s fortress at Beaurevoir.  From an estimated seventy feet in the air, Joan attempted to tie together pieces of bedding and cloth.  During the process these tore, sending her to the completely uncushioned ground below.  Most likely unconscious for two days, she eventually regained her vitality.  Possibly her escape was actually a suicide attempt but to admit such an inclination was again a grave blasphemy.

Joan of Arc, Vieux Marche, Rouen

Joan was dragged to the fourth and highest platform and chained and bound to the stake by the official executioner.  Later, he would complain that the stake was so high he could not apply the customary rope around the victim’s neck to employ strangulation, a merciful alternative to actual burning.  The condemned was wearing a gray, sleeveless garment that stretched below her knees.  On her head, a crude crown with the words “Heretic, relapse, apostate, idolater.”  Around her neck a small, wooden crucifix, fashioned for her at the last moment.  A sympathetic priest, assigned to comfort her in her last minutes returned to her vicinity with a tall crucifix that he had retrieved from a nearby church.  Joan shouted to him, the din from the jeering crowd rising with each passing minute. 

“Hold it before my eyes so I can see it until the last!!”

Cauchon’s obscured burial site today, Lisieux
Pierre Gauchon did not live to observe these developments.  He died of a heart attack at Rouen in December of 1442, still enjoying prominence and comfort under the protection of the English.
Joan of Arc statue, near stake location, Rouen, France

 

Joan of Arc (Volume 3, Episode 9) Book and Music Information

The following books were used to assemble this podcast:

Joan of Arc: Her Story, by Regine Pernoud

Joan of Arc: A Life Transfigured, Kathryn Harrison

Joan of Arc: A History, by Helen Castor

The intro in Part One is”Wistful Harp,” by Andrew Huang

The outro in Part One is “Last Train to Mars,”

The songs are reversed in Part Two

Charles Van Doren, Herbert Stempel and the 50’s Quiz Show Scandal (Volume 3, Episode 8) Part One

The true story of the television scandal that shocked America.

Charles Van Doren and Herb Stempel during their climactic game

The showdown between the two men continued on December 5, 1956, Stempel having accumulated 66,500 dollars.  The first show again resulted in a 21-21 tie.  The tension built as the dashing college educator tried to pull off the upset, but in the fourth game Herb Stempel pulled out to a 16-0 lead and seemed on the brink of successfully moving on.  21 had an interesting wrinkle in which contestants were asked after the second round of questions if they wished to stop the game.  Because they were in a soundproofed booth they did not know their opponent’s score and were instructed not to discuss specifics when their microphones and headsets were turned backed on.

Herb Stempel as he appeared in 21

His appearance on 21 should have been a life changing event and a stepping stone to prominence and further achievement.  But for a variety of reasons, it hadn’t turned out that way.  Stempel’s background was the complete inverse of Charles Van Doren.  An only child and a three year old when his father died, Stempel was raised by his mother who left him alone in their Bronx tenement while she worked during the day.  An excellent student with a 170 IQ, Stempel did graduate from the academically demanding Bronx High School of Science.  Like many Americans, he joined the Army in 1942 and remained in the military for eight years, eventually working in military intelligence.  He finally left the service in 1952 to enroll at the City College of NY.  While a student, Stempel survived on money provided by a trust fund set up for his wife, Toby, the daughter of a successful hosiery manufacturer. 

Vivian Nearing, Jack Barry and Charles Van Doren on the set of 21

Charles Van Doren finally met his match in Vivian Nearing, an attorney and the wife of a contestant that Van Doren already had defeated.  He was tripped up on a question involving obscure current ruling monarchs, failing to identify King Baudoin of Belgium.  But, along the way, Charles Van Doren became an overnight celebrity.  He won $128,000 on the program and appeared on the cover of the February 11, 1957 edition of Time Magazine with an accompanying glowing profile His appearance and popularity was so impressive that in April of 1957, he was offered a three year contract by NBC at fifty thousand dollars a year.

The Van Doren family
Van Doren was a telegenic, well spoken, sophisticated scion of one of the most intellectual families in America.  Despite some misgivings, especially from his fiancé, he agreed to appear.  Although he did not even own a television, he soon found himself on the soundstage of the program, initially to observe several shows from the wings and eventually to compete against Stempel, still the current champion.  Jack Barry’s introduction was inaccurate but certainly impressive: “He teaches music at Columbia University, and was a student at Cambridge University, in England . . . and his hobby is playing the piano in chamber-music groups.” Barry also referred specifically to Van Doren’s father and his literary stature and background. 
Richard Goodwin

The film Quiz Show focuses on the efforts of one person, Richard Goodwin, played by Rob Morrow, a congressional investigator whose supposed efforts singlehandedly brought the Quiz show scandal to public attention and congressional oversight.  In fact, long before Congress or Goodwin got involved, New York newspapers and the Manhattan District Attorney’s office were already investigating rumors and allegations swirling around several quiz show productions.  

Charles Van Doren, Herbert Stempel And the 50’s Quiz Show Scandal (Volume 3, Episode 8) Part 2

The true story of the television scandal that shocked America.

Charles Van Doren, 1959

On November 2, 1959, at 10 AM, Charles Van Doren and his attorney Carl Rubino entered the caucus room where the House Subcommittee hearings investigating potential game show corruption were conducted.  He had spent the previous evening accompanied by his wife and father at what must have been a very surreal dinner party at the home of Dick Goodwin, as this event was also attended by prosecutor Joseph Stone.

District Attorney Frank Hogan

Investigator Stone understood the potential volatility of the situation and he immediately personally briefed his boss, the District Attorney.  Frank Hogan was also skeptical of Stempel but for an additional reason.  He was a prominent alumnus of Columbia University, knew Professor Mark Van Doren personally and had even met Charles Van Doren.  He found it hard to believe that someone of the younger Van Doren’s background was capable of such duplicity but, at a formal news conference on August 28, Hogan did acknowledge that both Dotto and 21 were under investigation.  However, he also added that as yet the allegations were still unproven.

Richard Goodwin, a high level White House staff member during both the Kennedy and Johnson administrations.

Richard Goodwin quickly resigned from his subcommittee position and went to work for the Kennedy presidential campaign.  

Herbert Stempel, later years

Herb Stempel remained in an apartment not far from where he lived in Forest Hills, NY, in 1959, his phone number publicly accessible.  He lived well into his nineties, long retired from the Department of Transportation, Stempel and said he always knew when the film “Quiz Show” appeared on television.  Invariably, frequently in the middle of the night, his phone rang and the caller asked “What film won the award for best picture of 1955?”  Stempel always answered Marty, wished the caller a good evening and hung up the telephone.  He passed away on April 7, 2020, aged 93

 

Charles Van Doren, Herbert Stempel and the 50’s Quiz show Scandal (Volume 3, episode 8) Book and Music Information

Most of the information for this podcast came from the books

“Prime Time and Misdemeanors,” by Joseph Stone and Tim Yohn and

“Remembering America: A Voice From the Sixties,” by Richard Goodwin.

The Intro to Part One music is “Gaiety In The Golden Age,” by Aaron Kenny. Part One’s Outro is “The Black Cat,” also by Aaron Kenny.

Part Two’s Intro music is “Cover Charge,” by Track Tribe and the Outro is “Easy Lemon Sixty Second,” by Kevin Macleod.

Bob Marley (Volume 3, Episode 7) Part One

Homeless at age 19, in one of the poorest cities of the Third World, Bob Marley eventually created what Time Magazine called, “The greatest album of the Twentieth Century. 

Bob Marley, Dublin, Ireland, 1980

Robert Nesta Marley was born in Nine Mile, Jamaica on February 6, 1945 to Cedella Editha Malcolm and Norval Sinclair Marley.  Marley’s mother, a Jamaican of African descent was 18 years old.  His father, a Caucasian of British ancestry was 60.  Although Norval Marley has been described as a sea captain, British army officer and even quartermaster he was in fact a laborer and construction worker who never saw military action.  He lived and worked in Britain, Africa and the Caribbean and was employed as an overseer of the subdivision of the rural area around Nine Mile in the Jamaican province of St. Anne.    At the time of Bob Marley’s birth, Nine Mile had neither electricity or running water. 

Peter Tosh

Literally around the corner, on Third Street, a successful musician by the name of Joe Higgs routinely ran practice sessions with locals he deemed talented enough.  There, Bob and Bunny met another aspiring crooner named Winston Hubert McIntosh, eventually known as Peter Tosh, and Higgs decided the trio had something special. 

Bunny Livingston, aka, “Bunny Wailer”
One of Bob’s childhood friends in Nine Mile was nine year old Neville O’Reilly Livingston.  Neville was nicknamed “Bunny” and eventually would become an important part of Marley’s musical prominence but would eventually leave Nine Mile and move to Kingston with his father, Thaddeus “Toddy”Livingston.
Rita Marley

Finally, Bob Marley became so fed up with the situation that he decided that he would join his mother in Wilmington, Delaware.  He hoped to find work and save enough money to bankroll the Wailers own production and recording efforts allowing the musicians to retain control over the profits.  Before leaving, perhaps to reassure her, Bob made the decision to marry his longtime girlfriend, Rita.  He promised to return and the official wedding on February 10, 1966 underlined his commitment.

 

Bob Marley (Volume 3, Episode 7) Part 2

18, unemployed and homeless in one of the poorest cities of the Third World, Bob Marley eventually created what Time Magazine called, “The greatest album of the Twentieth Century.”

The I-Threes, Rita Marley, center

Meanwhile, in 1974, he was attempting to reorganize the Wailers and decide on his next musical direction.  He needed to replace the two most prominent departed, which he did with a trio of female backing vocalists that included his wife Rita, Marcia Griffiths and Judy Mowatt, dubbed as the I-Three. 

56 Hope Road, now a museum

Previously a dilapidated mansion in a posh Kingston neighborhood at 56 Hope Road, a house that Bob Marley eventually purchased outright.  Marley’s wife Rita was domiciled at Bull Bay, ten miles outside of Kingston, with the couple’s four children, including a son Stephen, born on April 20, 1972.  Marley spent much of his time at Hope Road pursuing various relatively open romantic relationships including one with Esther Anderson, a high profile employee of Island, as well as an actress and model who starred in several Hollywood feature films.

Ziggy Marley

 

Bob Marley (Volume 3, Episode 7) Book And Music Information

The books used during the composition of this podcast included:

Catch A Fire, by Timothy White

So Much Things To Say, by Roger Steffens

Bob Marley: A Life, by Gary Steckles

Bob Marley (Stories Behind the Songs)

The intro music to Part One and Two is: Thug Dub, by Quincas Moreira

The outro to Part One is: Feel Nice, by Rick Steel

crazy Horse (volume 3, episode 6) part one

In life, a prominent Lakota warrior chieftain, in death, an American legend
No photo of Crazy Horse has ever been authenticated, this sketch was verified by his sister after his death

Most likely, Crazy Horse was born in the spring of 1840, in the Black Hills of western South Dakota, near Rapid City.  His father was a member of the Oglala clan, also named Crazy Horse, and his mother, Rattle Blanket Woman was a Minniconju.

Marcus Reno

The Lakotas and Cheyenne were generally aware of the federal presence but believed that only a fool would attempt to attack such a large and powerful position.  But, at 3 PM, attack Custer did, ordering 140 cavalry on horseback under the command of Major Marcus Reno to engage the south side of the giant native village on the western shoreline of the Little Bighorn River.  Custer planned to take his command of 200 men and proceed along the river, ultimately leading an attack upon the northern side of the village. 

Frederick Benteen

Custer’s strategy, relying on his own success at the Washita and other battlefield experience, was simple.  He divided his 12 companies into three units.  Three companies commanded by Major Marcus Reno would attack the encampment from the South, Three would be commanded by Captain Frederick Benteen, held in reserve to pursue any subsequent advantage and five units would be lead by Custer himself, attacking the village from the North.  One unit would be held behind to customarily protect the regiment wagon train of material and ammunition.

General George A. Custer

Although weakened and disorganized, Crazy Horse and other non-treaty natives were adamant that they would not move on to a reservation.  Perhaps as a further attempt to intimidate them, in 1874, Phil Sheridan ordered General Custer to march directly into the Black Hills with a force of over one thousand well-equipped soldiers.  Accompanying the expedition were mining engineers who quickly determined that the entire region was replete with sizable gold deposits.  Custer, a shameless self promoter, also travelled with several journalists who wasted no time in informing an economically challenged American population that gold was everywhere in the Black Hills. 

He Dog, 1877

Unlike previous incidents, this time there was some warning of an attack and as Reno approached, numerous warriors on foot and on horseback rapidly emerged to bring this assault to an immediate halt.  The cavalry was quickly forced to dismount and set up a battle line that hastily became defensive.  Several Lakota chiefs, including He Dog and Brave Heart were soon involved in the fight but as the conflict escalated, one notable combatant remained absent.  The most respected and prominent Oglala warrior, Crazy Horse, was swimming in the river when the fighting started. 

Crow King

Custer’s initial strategy involved an attack on the northern edge of the  encampment, splitting his companies into two units, commanded by Myles Keough and George Yates, with Custer retaining overall command. This dual assault followed natural ravines in an attempted crossing of the Little Bighorn.  But Custer quickly ran into the same predicament as Reno.  He also ran into Crazy Horse as well as another native column lead by the Hunkpapa warrior chief Crow King.  By 4:35, Crazy Horse had traversed the two miles from the vicinity of the Reno skirmish and was now organizing a response to Custer’s aggression.  The Hunkpapa and Cheyenne contingent would confront the Yates column and quickly drive it backwards in retreat while Crazy Horse lead a one and a half mile ride of the Oglalas which forded the Little bighorn river at a spot known as Deep Ravine and then attacked the Custer-Keough battalion on its right rear flank.  Both battalions would eventually retreat to a spot known as Calhoun Hill.  They would be surrounded by the two separate native columns, Crazy Horse leading a looping encircling movement from the Northwest, Crow King pressing the attack from the South. 

Custer Marker, Little Big Horn Battlefield

Although Custer’s command is traditionally believed to have been wiped out on high ground now known as Custer Hill, how and exactly where the US detachment and Custer met their end is still a subject of academic debate.  Native descriptions indicate that the entire secondary battle took little more than an hour and the last surviving troops were overwhelmed by a final charge of warriors, the conflict now a desperate hand- to-hand struggle in which soldiers had no time to reload, and natives relied on war clubs and hatchets to attack and then kill.  Modern analysis indicates a final breakout attempt of two-dozen men who were trapped in a nearby canyon and then finished off.  Several warriors claimed credit for killing Custer but as one native participant eventually stated: “If we could have seen where each bullet landed, we might have known. But hundreds of bullets were flying that day.”

 

Crazy Horse (Volume Three, Episode six) Part Two

In life a prominent Lakota warrior-chieftain, in death an American legend.

Seven feet tall, “Touch the Clouds”

In his final moments of freedom, nervous and bewildered, Crazy Horse accepted the hand of Kennington who began to lead him to Fort Robinson’s jail within the guardhouse.  Lee facilitated this process by explaining to Touch the Clouds and the others that they should stay with Crazy Horse overnight and hopefully a meeting with Bradley could happen the next day.  Lee did not have the heart or the courage to admit that he knew that this would never happen.    

Little Big Man, hand obscuring wrist wound from Crazy Horse

The realization that he was about to be confined suddenly became clear to Crazy Horse.  In anticipation, both Kennington and Little Big Man attempted to restrain him but he escaped their grasp and lunged for the front door.   From under the red blanket he was wearing he produced a six-inch blade he typically used to cut tobacco and as Little Big Man grabbed him by both elbows, Crazy Horse cut a deep gash into his wrist.  The two continued to grapple in the doorway and Crazy Horse’s blanket fell to the ground.  Other natives attempted to restrain him but he continued to thrash wildly as Kennington finally drew his saber.  The captain quickly realized that the crush was too great and he began shouting repeatedly to the sentry: Stab the sonovabitch!  Like much of Crazy Horse’s life, what happened in the next few seconds is controversial but the result was undeniable.  Clearly injured by something, Crazy Horse, yelled “let me go, you’ve got me hurt now!,” His assailants released their grip and he groaned, staggered and fell to the ground.  Although official accounts would initially maintain that Crazy Horse stabbed himself with his own knife and then claim he accidentally was pushed against the bayonet of the sentry, his injury indicated otherwise.

Fort Robinson, site of Crazy Horse’s assassination

The injured warrior was placed on his blanket and carried into the administrative office.  Although an army cot was available, Crazy Horse insisted that he put on the ground.  There, he was examined by an agency doctor, Valentine McGillycuddy.  Understanding that Crazy Horse was slowly bleeding to death, he administered morphine intravenously, stopping the chief’s agony.  Night fell upon the agency, the parade ground deserted, only Captain Kennington, an officer of the guard and an interpreter remained as an official presence.  Touch the Clouds and his son, Charging First were also admitted.  Eventually, Crazy Horse’s father, Waglula and one of his step mothers, Red Moccasins, arrived at the agency and found their son.  Waglulla asked how he was doing.  Crazy Horse replied stoically: “I am hurt bad. I am going to die.  Tell the people they cannot depend on me anymore.”

Little Big Horn battlefield today.