All posts by Phil Gibbons

The Chicago Black Sox And The 1919 World Series (Volume 2, Episode 12) Part Two

The Chicago Black Sox and the scandal surrounding the 1919 World Series

The Eight Chicago Black Sox

“Regardless of the verdict of juries, no player that throws a ballgame; no player that undertakes or promises to throw a ballgame; no player that sits in a conference with a bunch of crooked players and gamblers where the ways and means of throwing games are planned and discussed and does not promptly tell his club about it, will ever play professional baseball.” Today, almost one hundred years later, all eight of these Chicago White Sox remain permanently banned, their statistics expunged from the official record.  This expulsion also affected even consideration for the Baseball Hall of Fame, a punishment that definitely affected Joe Jackson and possibly eliminated Eddie Cicotte and Buck Weaver, as well.

Shoeless Joe Jackson and Babe Ruth

The most prominent member of the Black Sox adopted a nonchalant attitude.  Shoeless Joe was quoted, “I’m through with organized baseball,” hinting that he would be just fine with his outside business interests which would be as lucrative as major league baseball.

Eddie Cicotte

In 1919, Eddie Cicotte, with bonuses and salary, earned $8,000, the second highest sum for a pitcher in the league, only Walter Johnson at 9,500, earned more.  Cicotte was also the eighth highest paid player in the league, and the oft repeated legend that Reds game one starter Dutch Ruether earned double what he was making is nonsensical.

Arnold “Chick” Gandil

On the road, Cicotte gravitated towards the company of first baseman Charles Arnold “Chick” Gandil, a tough, streetwise veteran player familiar to all of the habitués of taverns, pool halls and hotel bars that Gandil frequently haunted.  Although the exact origins and catalyst of the scheme to fix the 1919 World Series has never been specifically documented, it is believed that Chick Gandil and Eddie Cicotte were first approached in late September, 1919, in the vicinity of Boston’s Buckminster Hotel by Joseph “Sport” Sullivan, a well known professional gambler.

Dickie Kerr

Kerr, 5′ 7″, 155 lbs, was 13-7 during the regular season but was a big drop-off from Cicotte and Williams.  He was opposed by Ray Fisher, a solid major leaguer who went 14-5 in 1919.  Surprisingly, in Game 3, Kerr produced a three hit shutout, retiring the last fifteen Reds in a row.

Buck Weaver and Eddie Cicotte

 

The Chicago Black Sox and The 1919 World Series (Volume 2, Episode 12) Book and Music Information

The following books were used during the preparation of this podcast:

Betrayal: The 1919 World Series and the Birth of Modern Baseball, by Charles Fountain

The Betrayal: The 1919 World Series and the Birth of Modern Baseball

 

Fall From Grace: The Truth and Tragedy of Shoeless Joe Jackson, by Tim Hornbaker

Fall from Grace: The Truth and Tragedy of Shoeless Joe Jackson

 

Eight Men Out, by Eliot Asinof

Eight Men Out: The Black Sox and the 1919 World Series

Also, the SABR Journal Article “1919 Baseball Salaries and the Myth of the Underpaid Chicago White Sox,” by Bob Hoie

Chicago Black Sox Salaries

The Intro and Outro Music:

Scott Joplin, “The Entertainer”

Scott Joplin, “The Maple Leaf Rag”

DB Cooper (Volume 2, Episode 11) Part One

DB Cooper, the man behind the most notorious airplane hijacking in American history

The infamous sketches of DB Cooper

On November 24, 1971, a man walked up to the Northwest Orient ticket counter at the Portland, Oregon International Airport.  After waiting on line for a few moments, he paid $20 dollars in cash for a ticket for Flight 305 to Seattle, a scheduled 30 minute trip leaving at 2:50 PM.

The actual ticket used by “Dan Cooper” to fly from Portland to Seattle

He gave his name as “Dan Cooper” for the purposes of ticketing but he was not required to show identification.  Dressed in a dark suit, black tie and white shirt with a black raincoat he looked identical to any number of business travelers anxious to make it home for the following day’s Thanksgiving celebration.  He was assigned seat 18C, an aisle seat in the last row and boarded the plane with 36 other passengers, not including the crew.

Richard Floyd McCoy, Jr.

On April 7, 1972, a man flying under the alias “James Johnson” boarded flight 855 in Denver, Colorado.  The plane’s flight began on the East coast and was supposed to fly from Denver to Los Angeles.  It was a Boeing 727, the identical craft hijacked by D. B. Cooper.  James Johnson was actually a Mormon, national guard member , ex-Green Beret BYU student named Richard Floyd McCoy, Jr.  He sat in the last row on the aisle in the exact location used by Cooper.  Heavily made up and wearing a wig, McCoy hijacked the plane to San Francisco, claiming to have explosives, a grenade and a pistol, which he brandished at the flight attendants and some passengers who became aware of the situation when the plane rerouted to San Francisco.  McCoy demanded 500,000 dollars in different denominations and four parachutes.  He got the money and the chutes and got off the ground before agents could storm the plane. A duffel bag filled with the ransom money was attached to his parachute harness.  This time, the FBI and other law enforcement agencies were better prepared for such an eventuality.

DB Cooper (Volume 2, Episode 11) Part Two

DB Cooper, the man responsible for the most notorious air hijacking in US history.

The areas where Cooper may have landed in the state of Washington

On Thanksgiving morning, A Portland FBI investigator involved in the case, Ralph Himmelsbach, took it upon himself to use his own single engine plane to fly over the area where it is believed that Cooper might have bailed out.  He spends much of Thanksgiving Day flying back and forth over Vector 23, the route that flight 305 took through the area, trying to spot some trace of the hijacker.  A parachute, clothing, a campfire, even a body.  He comes up with nothing and, because of the poor weather and visibility, a full scale search on foot will not begin until Friday, November 26.  D. B. Cooper’s hijacking is the lead national network news story, beginning a public fascination with the case that will only increase over time.

The JC Penny tie, tie tack and ransom money recovered at the Tena Bar

In the immediate aftermath of the hijacking, the FBI, the chief law enforcement agency charged with investigating the case completely searched the airplane and meticulously interviewed witnesses, the flight crew and especially the two stewardesses who interacted with Cooper.  They uncovered numerous fingerprints ultimately determined to be useless, two of the four parachutes the hijacker left behind, a clip on tie that will turn out to be from Penney’s Department store, a pearl festooned tie clasp and eight cigarette butts of the brand “Raleigh”, a cheaper alternative to more high profile tobacco brands.

Ken Christiansen

Another notorious potential Cooper emerged in a 2007 New York Magazine article which identified a former deceased Northwest Orient purser named Kenneth Christansen as the hijacker.  Christiansen was implicated by his brother, Lyle, who repeatedly told the FBI and various investigators of his suspicion.   Along with the usual secretive deathbed confession while dying in 1994 of cancer, Chritiansen was an experienced paratrooper, a long time crew member with knowledge of a 727 and based out of Seattle.  Christiansen bought a house with cash shortly after the hijacking.  He died with an inexplicably large bank account, a valuable stamp collection, gold pieces and a strange, twenty year Northwest Orient scrapbook of news items that were related to the airline but ended right before the 1971 hijacking.  He smoked, drank whiskey and when Florence Schaffner was shown photos of Christiansen she agreed that he was photographically the closest match to Cooper that she had subsequently seen.  Unfortunately, Tina Mucklow, the flight attendant with the most contact with Cooper would eventually join a nunnery and refuse any interviews concerning the incident.  Two books would be written alleging that Christiansen was the hijacker, but his age in 1971, 45, and his small stature at 5’ 8”, 150 pounds which contradicted most eyewitness accounts make him a poor possibility.  The FBI ignored Christiansen from the start and Ralph Himmelsback personally ruled him out based on physical appearance alone.  Strangely, though the bureau also said that Christiansen was too skilled a paratrooper to have attempted the jump, implying that anyone who knew what they were doing would never have planned such a hijack in such weather and such a remote location.

Robert Rackstraw

Unfortunately, the notoriety surrounding DB Cooper has also precipitated many journalistic attempts to cash in on the topic.  This seems to be the case in the allegation that Robert Rackstraw, a former Vietnam veteran, helicopter pilot, ex-con and possible CIA operative is DB Cooper.  Rackstraw is a former university instructor and arbitrator who seems to have gotten his life together after a checkered past in the military.  In 2011, Thomas Colbert, a television journalist and law enforcement employee, began an extensively orchestrated investigation that concluded that Rackstraw is DB Cooper.  Over a five year period, Colbert’s team of various former FBI agents, Marshals and prosecuting attorneys sifted through various leads that lead them to individuals who were allegedly connected to the hijack.  It is Colbert’s allegation that three people colluded with Rackstraw and were waiting for him on the ground after Rackstraw jumped out of Flight 305.  Colbert’s team searched an area that an anonymous source told them was where Cooper actually landed and unearthed a parachute strap and pieces of a backpack that they turned over to the FBI.  In 2016, Colbert’s team also turned over information about Rackstraw and his accomplices that the bureau never investigated, instead officially closing the case on July 8, 2016, claiming that no new information had emerged and that the bureau did not have the resources to devote to a forty year plus cold case.  The FBI had already investigated Rackstraw in 1979 and concluded that he was not Cooper.  Colbert responded by maintaining that the FBI does not want to be embarrassed by a group of civilian investigators cracking the case and sued the FBI to release their files under the Freedom of Information Act.   Among the subsequently released maerial were several letters mailed to newspapers from an individual who claimed to be the hijacker.  One letter contains a numerical code that Colbert’s team claims Rackstraw would have known and utilized during his military service.  The numbers were a coded reference to Rackstraw’s elite Vietnam Army intelligence unit and as late as 2018, Colbert was trumpeting this as additional proof of Rackstraw’s secret identity and conveniently using this information to fund his second History Channel documentary on the topic.  Rackstraw’s alleged motive for the hijack was his anger over his discharge from the Army after falsifying his education and military exploits.  A 1970 photograph of Colbert also bears a strong resemblance to the Cooper drawing.  Rackstraw’s responses to Colbert’s investigation have ranged from threats to sue to elliptical statements neither confirming or denying his identity as DB Cooper.  Rackstraw has even hinted that he is in talks to produce his own version of his connection to the case but currently refuses to publicly discuss any connection to the crime.  Based on the FBI’s attitude, the best Colbert will ever be able to do is to convince a television audience that Rackstraw is DB Cooper and it is unlikely that this investigation will result in a prosecution.  However, as long as somebody is willing to finance his investigation, Colbert seems amenable to pursuing the case.

Richard F. McCoy grave in North Carolina. Was Richard McCoy actually DB Cooper?

DB Cooper (Volume 2, Episode 11) Podcast Book and Music Information

Most of the information for this podcast came from:

Skyjack: The Hunt for DB Cooper, by Geoffrey Gray

Skyjack: The Hunt for D. B. Cooper

 

Also: DB Cooper: The Real McCoy, by Bernie Rhodes and Russell Calame

D.B. Cooper: The Real McCoy

 

The music for this podcast came from:

Kevin Macleod: I Know A Guy and Vibe Ace

Also,  Quantum Jazz, End of Line

 

Robert E. Lee (Volume 2, Episode 10, Part 1)

Robert E. Lee, Valiant Hero or Misguided Traitor?

Robert E. Lee, 1845, With Son

Robert E. Lee was born on January 19, 1807.  He was the son of Henry Lee III and Anne Carter, Henry and Ann’s fifth child.

Robert E. Lee’s Wife And Daughter

Lee was initially assigned to assist in the construction of a fort on the Savannah River, 12 miles from the city of Savannah, Georgia itself.  But construction was unsuccessful and it would be sixteen years before Fort Pulaski was completed.  Long before that, Lee would be fortuitously reassigned to Fort Monroe, near present day Hampton, Virginia.  He visited Mary Custis at her family home, Arlington House, which overlooked the Potomac and Washington, DC.  Lee’s initial proposal to Mary Custis was accepted by her and her mother but her father, George Washington Parke Custis, the adopted son of George Washington and the grandson of Martha Washington was initially opposed.  Not only was Robert E. Lee from a family with limited financial resources, “Light Horse” Harry Lee’s questionable business practices had brought the hint of scandal to the entire Lee clan.

Thomas J. (Stonewall) Jackson, Photo Taken Only Weeks Before His Death

From a leadership perspective, Lee would also be forced to face the reality of the loss of Stonewall Jackson.  Initially thought to be able to recover from his gunshot wounds inflicted by friendly fire, Jackson contracted pneumonia and died on May 10.  Lee was uncharacteristically emotional in a letter to his son, Custis: “It is a terrible loss. I do not know how to replace him.  Such an executive officer the sun never shone on.  I have but to show him my design and if it can be done, it will be done.”

Lee and Jackson Commemorative Stamp, With Lee’s Ancestral Home, Stratford Hall

Both of Lee’s parents emanated from two of Virginia’s most aristocratic families.  Henry Lee III was a Revolutionary War cavalry officer who earned the nickname “Light Horse” for his equestrian ability during combat.  His mother’s family lived at Shirley, one of the oldest and most profitable tobacco plantations in the state of Virginia.  At the time of their marriage, Henry Lee was Virginia’s governor and would also serve the state as a member of the US House of Representatives.  However, by the time of Robert E. Lee’s birth, his father had suffered significant economic setbacks forcing the family to abandon the Lee ancestral home of Stratford Hall.

Robert E. Lee (Volume 2, Episode 10, Part 2)

Robert E. Lee: Valiant Hero or Misguided Traitor?

Arlington House, Occupied By Federal Troops, 1864

George Parke Custis was kicked out of Princeton, left St. John’s College of Annapolis after only one semester and made a living renting out all of the various plantation properties that he had inherited.  By comparison to the industrious and spartan Robert E. Lee, Custis was an indolent patrician who lived on the wealth of his ancestors. Eventually, understanding that his daughter was enthusiastic about marrying Lee, Mary Custis’ father agreed to the marriage of his only child, which took place at Arlington House on June 30, 1831.

Robert E. Lee and His Horse, Traveller

Lee immediately realized that the attack was not only a failure but a disaster.  On his horse Traveller he is said to have galloped forward and greeted his defeated troops by saying “It is my fault.”  Of Pickett’s 6,000 men, 3,000 were casualties including all 15 regimental commanders.  Other units suffered similarly bringing casualties to approximately 6,500 suffered in less than an hour.  Lee quickly became concerned that Meade might follow with a counterattack but when he ordered General Pickett to prepare his division for such an eventuality, Pickett is said to have replied, “General Lee, I have no division.”

Robert E. Lee, by Matthew Brady

Lee’s disappointment in his defeat at Gettysburg was so profound that he submitted his resignation to Jefferson Davis.  Lee indicated that he was to blame for the loss at Gettysburg and he questioned whether he could continue to meet the physical demands of military command.  Davis emphatically rejected Lee’s offer of resignation, telling him that replacing would be an impossibility.

Mary Lee, In Old Age

Lee did not live long enough to observe the post war reality of race relations, especially in the southern United States, but, based on the attitudes that both he and his wife expressed during their lifetime, he would not have found them problematic.

Washington and Lee University Commemorative Stamp

General Lee not even sure as to what he would do with the rest of his life.  He was 58 years old but other than the military he had no other occupation.  He must have considered it fortunate when the rector of Washington College in Lexington, VA offered him the presidency of the school.  Besides a salary which included a percentage of tuition, Lee was promised a residence.  In exchange he would administer the school and be asked to teach a course in philosophy.  Robert E. Lee accepted the position.

Robert E. Lee Chapel on the Campus of Washington and Lee University

In late September, Lee prepared for the beginning of Washington College’s 1870-1871 academic year.  On September 28, at a meeting of the directors of his local church, Lee’s last official act was to agree to make up the remaining $55 of the rector’s salary out of his own pocket.  He walked home and when he got to the dinner table, he was unable to lead his family in grace or even speak at all.  They sat him down and called a doctor, Lee clearly afflicted by some traumatic event which turned out to be a massive stroke.  Robert E. Lee lingered for two weeks, lying quietly in a bed in the main room of his home surrounded by family.  He died quietly on October 12, 1870, aged 63.  His glorification began immediately with a name change of Washington College to Washington and Lee University, Lee having initiated both law and business schools as part of the school’s curriculum.

View From Arlington House Today

Robert E. Lee will always remain a complex and fascinating figure of historical prominence.  Hopefully, the pendulum which initially swung too far in favor of insensitive adulation will eventually swing back from strident, out of context vilification to a more sensible middle ground

Robert E. Lee (Volume 2, Episode 10) Podcast Book And Music Information

Two books were essential during the recording of this podcast: Robert E. Lee: A Biography by Emory M. Thomas

Robert E. Lee: A Biography

 

Also, Lee: The Last Years, by Charles Bracelen Flood

Lee: The Last Years

 

Music used during the intro and outro included:

The Return To War, by The Art Of Escapism

And:

In Shadows, by William Ross

 

Herman Melville (Volume 2, Episode 9, Part 1)

Herman Melville: From obscurity to immortality

Herman Melville, 1861

When he died at age 72, on September 28, 1891, Herman Melville was so obscure that those who even remembered his literary output presumed that he had passed away many decades earlier.  Melville’s works were out of print, his last novel published more than thirty years before his death.  The title of his epic work Moby Dick was misspelled in Melville’s New York Times obituary and one of his most respected efforts, “Billy Budd, Sailor,” had not even been published.

Elizabeth Shaw Melville, Melville’s Wife

Despite the initial Shaw family misgivings about how their future son-in-law would make a living as a writer, Herman Melville and Elizabeth Shaw were married in Boston, in August of 1847.  They became permanent residents of New York City and the writer spent the next few years grinding out a succession of books.

Nathaniel Hawthorne

Packing off his family to his in-laws in Boston, in October, 1856, Melville first set out for Glasgow and then Liverpool and a meeting with his friend, now diplomat, Nathaniel Hawthorne.  Their reunion was friendly even warm but Hawthorne’s journal entries, while empathetic, depict Melville as a conflicted, lost soul.

Herman Melville (Volume 2, Episode 9, Part 2)

Herman Melville: From Obscurity to Immortality

Melville’s Massachusetts Home-Arrowhead

Over forty, Melville need not be concerned with actually having to fight for the Union but in 1863, he and his wife decided to move back to New York City, exchanging Arrowhead, which he was unable to sell, for his brother Allan’s East 26th Street home.

Herman Melville, Last Photograph, Mid-1880’s

Throughout this time period, Melville continued to toil away at his custom’s officer’s job.  When he began working at the Customs House in 1866 he took a horse drawn streetcar to work.  By the 1880’s, so much time had passed that Melville took the Third Avenue El, an elevated railway, to his office on the Upper East Side.

Elizabeth Shaw Melville, Later In Life

Melville would remain in this position until his resignation on December 31, 1885.  By that time, his wife had inherited a considerable amount of money from an aunt and other relatives, enough to allow Herman to retire.